Re: Project 1 preliminary critique
Posted: Mon Feb 15, 2021 1:18 pm
Wow. Man, this is a talented class. Sal, you're, I believe, the fourth person who has posted two equally good designs. Pick whichever one speaks to you.
The use of the Paris skyline photo is a good choice on your first one. It tells a story without needing words. Also, it adds a lot of visual interest to the background of your layout. The green is an interesting choice. It definitely works, but it also makes the whole thing look like an old school chalkboard. Your hand over the name is also an interesting choice. It adds such visual interest to the design and it's different color stands out against the green and white of the design. Good font selection as well. Your chosen fonts play well together, and the script type you have your name in looks like it was written out with chalk on the board. I like the diagonal direction of your layout with all the important content proceeding from the top left to the bottom right.
I'd recommend taking a picture of your hand where less of it is clipped off to the side so you have a full hand on the design. I would also be tempted to add just a touch of a background-matching green outer glow to your text to pop it off the background. It's currently getting a little caught up in the city detail, especially the class info and TMCC logo.
The photo collage on your second one is super strong. It visually tells so many stories that would take far too many words to say. I also like the font you chose for the "SAL BARAJAS ALVAREZ" text. It looks like and old billboard. The lack of color does not seem to be a drawback here. I expected it to be, but it gives the whole thing a film noir kind of look and feel. Your content is in pods all around the page, but it all gets tied together by the background image and the fact that they're not too far apart. I also like the bling sparkles as well. They look like some 60s TV show opening credits. Like your name has appeared in sparkles.
I think you've got a font too many on this one. The serif type works well the gothic type in your navigation, but clashes with the font you used in "SAL BARAJAS ALVAREZ". Maybe swap the serif bodycopy type with a sans-serif and see how that works with the "SAL BARAJAS ALVAREZ" type and the gothic type.
Excellent work!
The use of the Paris skyline photo is a good choice on your first one. It tells a story without needing words. Also, it adds a lot of visual interest to the background of your layout. The green is an interesting choice. It definitely works, but it also makes the whole thing look like an old school chalkboard. Your hand over the name is also an interesting choice. It adds such visual interest to the design and it's different color stands out against the green and white of the design. Good font selection as well. Your chosen fonts play well together, and the script type you have your name in looks like it was written out with chalk on the board. I like the diagonal direction of your layout with all the important content proceeding from the top left to the bottom right.
I'd recommend taking a picture of your hand where less of it is clipped off to the side so you have a full hand on the design. I would also be tempted to add just a touch of a background-matching green outer glow to your text to pop it off the background. It's currently getting a little caught up in the city detail, especially the class info and TMCC logo.
The photo collage on your second one is super strong. It visually tells so many stories that would take far too many words to say. I also like the font you chose for the "SAL BARAJAS ALVAREZ" text. It looks like and old billboard. The lack of color does not seem to be a drawback here. I expected it to be, but it gives the whole thing a film noir kind of look and feel. Your content is in pods all around the page, but it all gets tied together by the background image and the fact that they're not too far apart. I also like the bling sparkles as well. They look like some 60s TV show opening credits. Like your name has appeared in sparkles.
I think you've got a font too many on this one. The serif type works well the gothic type in your navigation, but clashes with the font you used in "SAL BARAJAS ALVAREZ". Maybe swap the serif bodycopy type with a sans-serif and see how that works with the "SAL BARAJAS ALVAREZ" type and the gothic type.
Excellent work!